Speaking Boost · C1 · Lesson 48 of 50
Speaking Boost C1 · Block 10: Big Questions and Final Talk

What can history teach us?

People say that those who forget the past will repeat it. Discuss whether history gives us lessons, and learn narrative tenses and time linkers: past perfect continuous, by the time, ever since, in the wake of, prior to, subsequently, no sooner… than.

1

Warm-up

5 min
1.1

History and evidence

Answer each question with 2–3 sentences.

  1. Which period of history interests you most?
  2. Did you enjoy history at school?
  3. Which historical person would you like to meet?
  4. Which event do you wish you had seen?
  5. Do you think people learn from the past?
  6. Do you know your family's history?
2

Words and phrases

12 min
2.1

New words

Read each word and the example. Then say a sentence about history.

2.2

Which word?

Choose the word that fits.

  1. With the benefit of , it is easy to see mistakes that nobody noticed at the time.
  2. An earlier case used as a guide for later decisions is a .
  3. The order in which events happened is called their .
  4. Historians search the national for old letters and official documents.
  5. Two historians may the same evidence in very different ways.
  6. During wars, governments often use to influence public opinion.
  7. It is tempting to history by blaming a single cause for a complex event.
  8. Many cities the end of the war with a ceremony each year.
2.3

Opposites and pairs

Choose the right answer, then press Check answers.

  1. hindsight is understanding after an event has
  2. a precedent is an earlier
  3. chronology is the
    of events
  4. an archive is a collection of
  5. propaganda is information used to
    opinion
  6. to commemorate = to
    with a ceremony
2.4

Useful phrases

Use these phrases to tell the story of past events.

  • By the time...Коли..., (вже)By the time help arrived, they had left.
  • Ever since...З того часу, як...Ever since the war, the town has changed.
  • In the wake of...Услід за..., після...In the wake of the crisis, new rules appeared.
  • Prior to...До..., перед...Prior to the war, trade had been growing.
  • No sooner had... than...Щойно..., як...No sooner had it ended than it began again.
  • At the time,...Тоді,...At the time, nobody knew what would follow.
  • Up until then,...До того часу,...Up until then, nobody had imagined it.
  • Subsequently,...Згодом,...Subsequently, the treaty was revised.
3

Read and react

8 min
3.1

The lessons of the past

Read the text. Hover over the dotted words for help.

What can history teach us?

What can history teach us? The philosopher George Santayana wrote in 1905 that those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it, and the line is often quoted, usually in slightly altered form. But does history really repeat itself?

Many people point to the years after the First World War. By the time the Treaty of Versailles was signed in 1919, millions had died and economies had been strained for years, and some historians argue that its harsh terms helped to create bitterness that later fed extremism, although others say that the picture is more complicated. After the Second World War, by contrast, the United States offered the Marshall Plan from 1948, a programme of aid worth roughly thirteen billion dollars, and many economists believe that it helped Western Europe to recover. Ever since, politicians have cited these cases as lessons, a precedent to follow or avoid.

Historians are careful here. They remind us that every era is different, and that it is tempting to oversimplify. With the benefit of hindsight, events look inevitable; at the time, nobody knew what was coming. People who were living through the 1918 influenza pandemic had not been told how it would end, and in the wake of the crisis, some countries remembered it far better than others.

What history can offer, perhaps, is not a set of rules but a pattern of questions: who gained, who was left out, what had been ignored? Historians check the evidence in the archive and compare accounts, because the same documents may be read in different ways.

So what can history teach us? Probably humility. It cannot tell us what will happen, but it can warn us how often we have been sure and wrong.

Which event from history would you like to understand better?

3.2

True or false?

  1. Santayana's line is often quoted in slightly altered form.
  2. The text says that historians all agree about the Treaty of Versailles.
  3. The Marshall Plan began in 1948.
  4. The text says that events looked inevitable to people at the time.
  5. The text says that historians compare accounts and check the evidence.
3.3

What do you think?

  1. Does history repeat itself?
  2. Which event do people most misunderstand?
  3. Is it fair to judge the past by today's values?
  4. Who writes history, and why does it matter?
4

Grammar for speaking

10 min
4.1

Grammar for speaking

Narrative tenses

Use the past simple for the main events, the past continuous for background and action in progress, the past perfect for earlier events, and the past perfect continuous for an earlier action that continued for some time.

The treaty was signed in 1919. Millions were suffering. By then, many had died. She had been working in the archive for years when she found the letter.

Time linkers

Use by the time + past simple (main clause often past perfect), ever since + present perfect, prior to and in the wake of + noun, no sooner had... than..., up until then, at the time and subsequently to show the order of events.

By the time help arrived, they had left. Ever since the war, the town has changed. Prior to the war, trade had been growing. No sooner had it ended than it began again.

Block 10 review

Use the grammar from this block.

big statements: cleft sentences, correlatives, parallelism (L46) · generalising and qualifying (L47)

Common mistakes: by the time + past simple, past perfect, prior to + noun, in the wake of + noun, no sooner had… than… and ever since + present perfect. ✗ By the time he came, they left → had left. ✗ Prior the war → Prior to the war. ✗ In the wake the crisis → In the wake of the crisis. ✗ No sooner had it begun when → than. ✗ Ever since then, it changed → has changed.

4.2

Choose the right form

  1. By the time the treaty was signed, millions
    .
  2. She
    in the archive for years when she found the letter.
  3. the war, trade had been growing.
  4. In the wake
    the crisis, new rules were introduced.
  5. No sooner had the war ended
    famine spread.
  6. Up until then, nobody
    such losses.
  7. , the treaty was revised.
  8. People
    through the crisis and did not know how it would end.
4.3

Fix the mistake

Each sentence has one mistake. Type the correct words.

  1. By the time the war ended, millions died. →
  2. She worked in the archive for years when she found the letter. →
  3. Prior the war, trade was growing. →
  4. In the wake the crisis, new rules appeared. →
  5. No sooner had the war ended when famine spread. →
  6. Ever since the war, the town changed a lot. →
4.4

Talk about it

Answer in detail. Use narrative tenses and time linkers.

  1. By the time you were ten, what had you already learned?
  2. Tell the story of an event in your family history. Use the past perfect.
  3. What happened in your country in the wake of an important event?
  4. Ever since you started learning English, what has changed?
  5. What was happening in the world when you were born?
  6. No sooner had you finished school than...? Finish the story.
5

Three views and a short talk

8 min
5.1

Three views on the lessons of history

Three people discuss the lessons of history. Compare them. Who trusts history most? Who trusts it least? Whose view is closest to yours?

Person 1

Dr Almeida, 57

  • Is a historian
  • Had been studying the archive for years
  • Says history gives patterns, not rules
  • Warns against oversimplifying
Person 2

Nadia, 19

  • Is a history student
  • Says that by the time she finished the book, she had changed her mind
  • Loves primary sources
  • Wants to work in a museum
Person 3

Mr Walker, 72

  • Lived through a big social change
  • Says that prior to it, life was simpler
  • Remembers the day clearly
  • Believes people forget quickly
5.2

Mini-talk: a lesson from the past

Your teacher will time you.

  1. Plan for one minute, then speak for one or two minutes.
  2. Part 1: describe a historical event that you find important.
  3. Part 2: use at least three narrative tenses or time linkers (by the time, ever since, in the wake of, prior to, no sooner... than).
  4. Part 3: say what you think people can learn from it.
2:00
6

Personal questions

10 min
6.1

Part I: Me

  1. What is your favourite period of history?
  2. Do you visit museums?
  3. Do you know a story from your family's past?
  4. Have you ever read a history book for pleasure?
  5. Which historical film have you enjoyed?
  6. Do you watch documentaries?
  7. Do you think history is taught well?
  8. Which date do you remember best?
6.2

Part II: Other people

  1. Who in your family tells stories about the past?
  2. Who is your favourite historical figure?
  3. Who should write school history books?
  4. Who taught you about history?
  5. Who lived through a major event in your family?
  6. Who would you interview about the past?
6.3

Part III: A bit deeper

  1. Does history repeat itself?
  2. Can we learn from past mistakes?
  3. Should history lessons be changed?
  4. Is it right to remove statues of historical figures?
  5. Who owns the past?
7

Roleplay

12 min
7.1

Telling a story from the past

You

Speaker

A friend (your teacher) asks about a historical event you know:
  • set the scene
  • tell what happened using narrative tenses
  • say what changed afterwards
  • give your view
Speak for at least 2 minutes in total. Use by the time, ever since, in the wake of.
Your teacher

Friend

Says things like:
  1. Tell me about this event.
  2. What happened before?
  3. And afterwards?
  4. What can we learn from it?
7.2

Discussing the lessons of history

You

Speaker

You are in a discussion group (your teacher):
  • say what history can teach
  • give an example
  • respond to a different view
  • use three time linkers
You do most of the talking. Use: by the time... · ever since... · prior to... · no sooner had... than
Your teacher

Group member

Says things like:
  1. History teaches nothing.
  2. Can you give an example?
  3. But people repeat mistakes.
  4. What do you conclude?
8

Homework

at home

Your homework score

Do all four exercises, then press Check all homework. Correct answers will appear next to your mistakes.

– / 30
H1

Complete with a word

hindsightprecedentchronologyarchiveinterpretpropagandaoversimplifycommemorate
  1. With the benefit of , it is easy to see mistakes that nobody noticed at the time.
  2. An earlier case used as a guide for later decisions is a .
  3. The order in which events happened is called their .
  4. Historians search the national for old letters and official documents.
  5. Two historians may the same evidence in very different ways.
  6. During wars, governments often use to influence public opinion.
  7. It is tempting to history by blaming a single cause for a complex event.
  8. Many cities the end of the war with a ceremony each year.
H2

Choose the correct form

  1. By the time we arrived, the film .
  2. He for an hour when she came.
  3. the trip, we booked a hotel.
  4. In the wake the storm, many roads closed.
  5. No sooner had we sat down it began to rain.
  6. Up until then, I snow.
  7. , the shop closed.
  8. They home when it began.
H3

Correct or incorrect?

Decide if each sentence is grammatically correct.

  1. By the time help arrived, they had left.
  2. By the time help arrived, they left.
  3. Prior to the war, trade had been growing.
  4. Prior the war, trade had been growing.
  5. In the wake of the crisis, new rules appeared.
  6. No sooner had it ended than it began again.
  7. No sooner had it ended when it began again.
H4

Match the two halves

  1. By the time help arrived,
  2. Ever since the war,
  3. In the wake of the crisis,
  4. Prior to the war,
  5. No sooner had it ended
  6. At the time,
  7. Up until then,

Finished the lesson?

Mark it as complete to keep track of your progress.