Speaking Boost · B2 · Lesson 28 of 50
Speaking Boost B2 · Block 6: History and Culture

What happened to the Library of Alexandria?

The Library of Alexandria was one of the greatest centres of knowledge in the ancient world, and its end is still discussed. Learn to talk about historical "what ifs" with the third conditional, and to express regret and criticism about the past.

1

Warm-up

5 min
1.1

Libraries and knowledge

Answer each question with 2–3 sentences.

  1. Do you use libraries? What for?
  2. What is your favourite book?
  3. Which book would you save from a fire?
  4. What do you think was lost in history?
  5. Have you ever lost something important?
  6. Do you often think "what if"?
2

Words and phrases

12 min
2.1

New words

Read each word and the example. Then say a sentence about libraries.

2.2

Which word?

Choose the word that fits.

  1. In ancient times, books were written on a .
  2. A is a person who studies a subject deeply.
  3. The library's was said to contain hundreds of thousands of scrolls.
  4. Many historians think the decline was , not sudden.
  5. Some scrolls managed to in other libraries.
  6. The library lost money when its ruler cut the .
  7. The story of one big fire may be a .
  8. The of knowledge is a tragedy for everyone.
2.3

Opposites and pairs

Choose the right answer, then press Check answers.

  1. a scroll is a
  2. a scholar is a person who
  3. to destroy = to
  4. gradual = happening
  5. a myth is a popular story that is
  6. to survive = to
2.4

Useful phrases

Use these phrases to talk about what would have happened.

  • If the library had survived,...Якби бібліотека вціліла,...If the library had survived, we would know more.
  • If they hadn't cut the budget,...Якби вони не скоротили бюджет,...If they hadn't cut the budget, it might have lasted.
  • We would have learned...Ми б дізналися...We would have learned much more about the past.
  • It might have survived if...Вона могла б вціліти, якби...It might have survived if rulers had supported it.
  • They should have copied...Їм слід було скопіювати...They should have copied more scrolls.
  • If only they had...Якби ж вони...If only they had made more copies.
  • What would have happened if...?Що б сталося, якби...?What would have happened if the scrolls had been copied?
  • Historians disagree about...Історики не погоджуються щодо...Historians disagree about how it ended.
3

Read and react

8 min
3.1

The lost library

Read the text. Hover over the dotted words for help.

What happened to the Library of Alexandria?

The Library of Alexandria was founded in Egypt in the third century BCE, under the Greek-speaking Ptolemy rulers. It was part of a larger institution called the Mouseion, where scholars studied mathematics, medicine, astronomy and literature. The rulers wanted to collect the knowledge of the world, and they are said to have ordered that books on arriving ships should be copied.

No one knows exactly how many scrolls the library held. Ancient writers gave numbers from tens of thousands to several hundred thousand, but modern scholars think that many of these numbers are exaggerated.

The popular story says that the library was destroyed in a single great fire. Historians say that the truth is more complicated. A fire during Julius Caesar's war in 48 BCE damaged part of the city, and perhaps some books, but the library continued to exist. Over the next centuries, funds were reduced, scholars left, and the city suffered from wars. The final decline was therefore gradual.

Many people say that if the library had survived, we would know much more about the ancient world. That may be true, but it is important to remember that many ancient texts did survive because they had been copied by scholars elsewhere.

The lesson is clear: knowledge needs not only great buildings, but also people and money to preserve it.

Which texts from your culture would you save first?

3.2

True or false?

  1. The library was founded in the third century BCE.
  2. Historians agree that one fire destroyed the library.
  3. Ancient writers agree on the exact number of scrolls.
  4. The decline of the library was gradual.
  5. The text says that no ancient text has survived.
3.3

What do you think?

  1. What do you think we would know today if the library had survived?
  2. Which is more dangerous for knowledge: fire, war or lack of money?
  3. How can we protect knowledge today?
  4. Why are myths about history so popular?
4

Grammar for speaking

10 min
4.1

Grammar for speaking

Third conditional

If + Past Perfect, would have + past participle. It describes an unreal situation in the past, often a regret or a criticism.

If the library had survived, we would know more. If they hadn't cut the budget, it might have lasted. What would have happened if the scrolls had been copied?

Should have, could have, might have

Should have + past participle: it was the right thing but it did not happen. Could have or might have: it was possible.

They should have copied more scrolls. They could have saved the books. It might have survived with more support.

Block 6 review

Use the grammar from this block.

Past Perfect and past passive (L26) · Past Perfect passive, linking past events (L27)

Common mistakes: if + had + past participle, would have + past participle, and never would after if. ✗ If the library survived, we would have known → If the library had survived. ✗ If I would have known → If I had known.

4.2

Choose the right form

  1. If the library
    , we would know more.
  2. If they
    the budget, it might have lasted.
  3. If the king
    more, the scholars would have stayed.
  4. What
    if the scrolls had been copied?
  5. They
    copied more scrolls.
  6. They
    saved the books if they had acted.
  7. If she
    , she would have helped.
  8. It
    with more support.
4.3

Fix the mistake

Each sentence has one mistake. Type the correct words.

  1. If the library survived, we would have known more. →
  2. If they hadn't cut the budget, it would last. →
  3. If scholars would have stayed, the library would have survived. →
  4. They should saved more books. →
  5. What would happen if the scrolls had been copied? →
  6. If I had known, I will have helped. →
4.4

Talk about it

Answer in detail. Use the third conditional and should have, could have, might have.

  1. What would have happened if the library had survived?
  2. What decision in your life would you change if you could?
  3. If you had lived in Alexandria, what would you have studied?
  4. What should people have done to protect the library?
  5. Which of your possessions would you have saved from a fire?
  6. What do you think we will lose in the future if we are not careful?
5

Three views on the lost library and a short talk

8 min
5.1

Three views on the lost library

Three people think about the lost library. Compare their views. Who is the most critical? Who is the most hopeful about preserving knowledge today? What would you have done?

Person 1

Dr Amira, 48

  • Is a historian
  • Says the decline was gradual
  • Thinks one fire is a myth
  • Would have liked to visit the library
Person 2

Leo, 19

  • Is a history student
  • Believed the big fire story
  • Is surprised by new evidence
  • Says more scrolls should have been copied
Person 3

Mr Stone, 62

  • Is a modern librarian
  • Digitises old books
  • Says a backup would have saved many works
  • Worries about budgets
5.2

Mini-talk: what if?

Your teacher will time you.

  1. Plan for one minute, then speak for one or two minutes.
  2. Part 1: tell what you know about the library.
  3. Part 2: what would have happened if it had survived (third conditional).
  4. Part 3: what we should preserve today, and how.
2:00
6

Personal questions

10 min
6.1

Part I: Me

  1. What would you have done in ancient Alexandria?
  2. What book would you save from a fire?
  3. Do you prefer paper books or digital ones?
  4. What would have happened if you hadn't studied English?
  5. What decision would you change?
  6. What should you have done differently this week?
  7. Do you keep old letters or photos?
  8. Have you ever lost something you wish you still had?
6.2

Part II: Other people

  1. Who in your family reads the most?
  2. Who would you have asked about the past?
  3. Who should have been more careful?
  4. Who would have helped you if you had asked?
  5. Who do you know that works in a library?
  6. Who keeps family documents?
6.3

Part III: A bit deeper

  1. Should all knowledge be free?
  2. Should governments pay for libraries?
  3. Is digital storage safer than paper?
  4. What would the world be like if the library had survived?
  5. Should we keep everything, or only the best?
7

Roleplay

12 min
7.1

Discussing a lost treasure

You

Historian

You discuss the library with a student (your teacher):
  • say what happened
  • correct the popular myth
  • say what would have happened if it had survived
  • suggest what we can learn
Speak for at least 2 minutes in total. Use the third conditional.
Your teacher

Student

Says things like:
  1. Was it one fire?
  2. What was lost?
  3. How do we know?
  4. What can we learn?
7.2

Talking about regrets

You

Speaker

A friend (your teacher) asks about a decision you regret:
  • say what you did
  • say what you should have done
  • say what would have happened
  • say what you learned
You do most of the talking. Use: If I had..., I would have... · I should have... · If only I had...
Your teacher

Friend

Says things like:
  1. What happened?
  2. Do you regret it?
  3. What would you do now?
  4. What did you learn?
8

Homework

at home

Your homework score

Do all four exercises, then press Check all homework. Correct answers will appear next to your mistakes.

– / 30
H1

Complete with a word

scrollscholarcollectiongradualsurvivebudgetmythloss
  1. In ancient times, books were written on a .
  2. A is a person who studies a subject deeply.
  3. The library's was said to contain hundreds of thousands of scrolls.
  4. Many historians think the decline was , not sudden.
  5. Some scrolls managed to in other libraries.
  6. The library lost money when its ruler cut the .
  7. The story of one big fire may be a .
  8. The of knowledge is a tragedy for everyone.
H2

Choose the correct form

  1. If I , I would have helped.
  2. If it , we would have gone out.
  3. She would have won if she more.
  4. What in my place?
  5. We left earlier.
  6. He passed the exam if he had studied.
  7. If they , I would have told them.
  8. It a mistake.
H3

Correct or incorrect?

Decide if each sentence is grammatically correct.

  1. If the library had survived, we would know more.
  2. If the library survived, we would have known more.
  3. If they hadn't cut the budget, it might have lasted.
  4. If I had known, I will have helped.
  5. They should have copied more scrolls.
  6. They should saved more books.
  7. What would have happened if the scrolls had been copied?
H4

Match the two halves

  1. If the library had survived,
  2. If they hadn't cut the budget,
  3. We would have learned
  4. It might have survived
  5. They should have
  6. If only they
  7. Historians disagree

Finished the lesson?

Mark it as complete to keep track of your progress.