Speaking Boost · B2 · Lesson 9 of 50
Speaking Boost B2 · Block 2: Work and Money

Why did a flower once cost more than a house?

In the Netherlands of the 1630s, tulip bulbs became a hot trade, and the story of what happened is still told today. Learn to report what is said and believed with passive structures, and to talk about risk and hype.

1

Warm-up

5 min
1.1

Markets and risk

Answer each question with 2–3 sentences.

  1. Have you ever bought something just because everybody wanted it?
  2. Do you prefer to save money or to spend it?
  3. What is the most expensive thing you've ever bought?
  4. Do you think rare things are always valuable?
  5. Have you ever heard a story about someone who lost a fortune?
  6. Would you invest money in something risky?
2

Words and phrases

12 min
2.1

New words

Read each word and the example. Then say a sentence about money and risk.

2.2

Which word?

Choose the word that fits.

  1. When is high and supply is low, prices rise.
  2. Some rare bulbs were sold for a .
  3. Many people tried to in tulips to make quick money.
  4. The market and prices fell in a few days.
  5. Economists call it a when prices go far above real value.
  6. The painting was sold at an for a high price.
  7. Historians think the stories may be .
  8. Gardeners plant in autumn.
2.3

Opposites and pairs

Choose the right answer, then press Check answers.

  1. demand is how much people
  2. a fortune is a
  3. to collapse = to
  4. a bubble is when prices go
  5. to exaggerate = to say something is
  6. an auction is a sale where people
2.4

Useful phrases

Use these phrases to report what is said or believed.

  • It is said that...Кажуть, що...It is said that one bulb cost more than a house.
  • It is believed that...Вважається, що...It is believed that the bubble burst in 1637.
  • ...is said to have......нібито...A bulb is said to have cost more than a house.
  • ...is thought to be......вважається...The story is thought to be exaggerated.
  • It may be that...Можливо, що...It may be that the stories were exaggerated.
  • Historians have found that...Історики виявили, що...Historians have found that few people were ruined.
  • Prices went up and down.Ціни то росли, то падали.Prices went up and down very quickly.
  • Don't believe the hype.Не вір галасу навколо.Don't believe the hype; check the facts.
3

Read and react

8 min
3.1

Tulip mania

Read the text. Hover over the dotted words for help.

Why did a flower once cost more than a house?

In the 1630s, in the Dutch Republic, tulips were a new and fashionable flower. They had come from the Ottoman Empire, and wealthy people wanted rare varieties with colourful stripes. Today we know that the stripes were caused by a virus, which also made the plants weaker and the bulbs harder to produce.

It is said that prices went up so fast that a single rare bulb could cost more than a house. In early 1637, the market is believed to have collapsed suddenly. Newspapers and books later described this as the first great financial bubble.

However, modern historians have looked at the records again. The historian Anne Goldgar, for example, found that the trade was smaller than the legend says and that few people seem to have been completely ruined. It may be that the story has been exaggerated over time.

Whatever the truth is, the story is still used as a warning. Economists use the word "bubble" for any market where prices rise far above real value and then fall. When people say "tulip mania", they often mean a situation in which hype and greed replace careful thinking.

Can you think of a modern example?

3.2

True or false?

  1. Tulips came to the Dutch Republic from the Ottoman Empire.
  2. The stripes on the flowers were caused by a virus.
  3. Historians agree that the legend is completely true.
  4. Anne Goldgar found that few people seem to have been completely ruined.
  5. The text says the story is no longer used as a warning.
3.3

What do you think?

  1. Why do people follow a trend even when prices are very high?
  2. Is there a modern example of a bubble?
  3. How can we protect ourselves from hype?
  4. Why do stories like this stay popular for centuries?
4

Grammar for speaking

10 min
4.1

Grammar for speaking

Passive reporting structures

It is said / believed / thought that + clause. Or: subject + is said / believed / thought + to-infinitive. For an earlier event use to have + past participle.

It is said that a bulb cost more than a house. A bulb is said to have cost more than a house. Tulips are believed to have come from the Ottoman Empire.

Passive with modals

can / could / must / should / may + be + past participle.

Prices could be controlled. The story may be exaggerated. Bulbs must be planted in autumn.

Block 2 review

Use the grammar from this block.

Present Perfect or Past Simple (L6) · Present Perfect Continuous (L7) · the passive (L8)

Common mistakes: is said to + infinitive, and to have + past participle for earlier events. ✗ He is believed having lost → He is believed to have lost. ✗ It says that → It is said that.

4.2

Choose the right form

  1. It
    that a bulb cost more than a house.
  2. A bulb is said
    more than a house.
  3. Tulips are believed
    from the Ottoman Empire.
  4. The story
    exaggerated.
  5. Prices
    controlled by the government.
  6. It
    that the bubble burst in 1637.
  7. She is
    to be rich.
  8. Bulbs
    planted in autumn.
4.3

Fix the mistake

Each sentence has one mistake. Type the correct words.

  1. It says that the market collapsed quickly. →
  2. He is believed having lost everything. →
  3. The story may exaggerated. →
  4. They are thought to had been rich. →
  5. Rules must followed. →
  6. Tulips believe to have come from Turkey. →
4.4

Talk about it

Answer in detail. Use It is said that… and is believed to…

  1. Tell me about something that is said to be very valuable.
  2. What is believed about money in your culture?
  3. What stories about getting rich quickly do you know?
  4. Have you ever followed a trend that you later regretted?
  5. How should people be protected from financial hype?
  6. What advice would you give to a new investor?
5

Three people and money, and a short talk

8 min
5.1

Three people and money

Three people deal with money in different ways. Compare them. Who takes the biggest risk? Who is the most careful? What advice would you give each one?

Person 1

Jan, 40

  • Bought shares at the top of the market
  • Is losing money
  • Thinks the market will recover
  • Feels stressed
Person 2

Eva, 29

  • Invests small amounts every month
  • Reads about the economy
  • Ignores the hype
  • Is patient
Person 3

Leo, 22

  • Bought a rare digital item
  • Hopes its price will rise
  • Follows social media advice
  • Has borrowed money
5.2

Mini-talk: money and risk

Your teacher will time you.

  1. Plan for one minute, then speak for one or two minutes.
  2. Part 1: what you spend money on and what you save for.
  3. Part 2: a time when you bought something because of hype, or saw others do it.
  4. Part 3: whether a bubble could happen today, and what is said about it.
2:00
6

Personal questions

10 min
6.1

Part I: Me

  1. What do you spend most of your money on?
  2. Have you ever bought something because of hype?
  3. What would you invest in?
  4. Do you save regularly?
  5. What rare thing would you like to own?
  6. Have you ever lost money?
  7. Do you check prices before you buy?
  8. How do you decide what is worth buying?
6.2

Part II: Other people

  1. Who in your family is good with money?
  2. Who loves bargains?
  3. Who has bought something very expensive?
  4. Who has given you advice about money?
  5. Who do you know that collects something rare?
  6. Who takes the most financial risks?
6.3

Part III: A bit deeper

  1. Can a bubble happen today?
  2. Should investing be taught at school?
  3. Is greed the main reason for financial crashes?
  4. Should the government stop risky trades?
  5. Is it right to make money from rare things?
7

Roleplay

12 min
7.1

Giving investment advice

You

Adviser

A friend (your teacher) wants to put all his savings into a new trend. Advise him:
  • ask what he wants to buy
  • explain the risk of a bubble
  • say what is believed about the market
  • suggest a safer plan
Speak for at least 2 minutes in total. Use passive reporting structures.
Your teacher

Friend

Says things like:
  1. Everyone is buying this!
  2. Prices are rising fast.
  3. I can't lose, can I?
  4. Maybe I should wait.
7.2

Telling a story

You

Storyteller

You tell the story of tulip mania to a group (your teacher):
  • explain what is said to have happened
  • say what historians believe now
  • compare it with a modern example
  • ask what the listeners think
You do most of the talking. Use: It is said that... · is believed to have... · may be exaggerated
Your teacher

Listener

Says things like:
  1. When did this happen?
  2. Is that really true?
  3. Does this happen today?
  4. What have we learned?
8

Homework

at home

Your homework score

Do all four exercises, then press Check all homework. Correct answers will appear next to your mistakes.

– / 30
H1

Complete with a word

demandfortuneinvestcollapsedbubbleauctionexaggeratedbulbs
  1. When is high and supply is low, prices rise.
  2. Some rare bulbs were sold for a .
  3. Many people tried to in tulips to make quick money.
  4. The market and prices fell in a few days.
  5. Economists call it a when prices go far above real value.
  6. The painting was sold at an for a high price.
  7. Historians think the stories may be .
  8. Gardeners plant in autumn.
H2

Choose the correct form

  1. It that the shop opened in 1900.
  2. The castle is said very old.
  3. He is thought the country in 1990.
  4. The rules changed.
  5. Prices checked online.
  6. It that money can't buy love.
  7. The bridge is known dangerous.
  8. Mistakes made by anyone.
H3

Correct or incorrect?

Decide if each sentence is grammatically correct.

  1. It is said that a bulb cost more than a house.
  2. He is believed having lost everything.
  3. The story may be exaggerated.
  4. Rules must followed.
  5. Tulips are believed to have come from the Ottoman Empire.
  6. They are thought to had been rich.
  7. Prices could be controlled.
H4

Match the two halves

  1. It is said that
  2. It is believed that
  3. A bulb is said
  4. The story is thought
  5. Historians have found
  6. Prices went up
  7. Don't believe

Finished the lesson?

Mark it as complete to keep track of your progress.